Dawoodi Bohra Forum

Yes I respect Umar RA ,there are reformist Shia who have realised there is no sin to respect the Khalifas and revere Ahlul Bayt just as reformist Sunni who respect Ahlul Bayt and Khalifa Rashidun. This is my direct warning to the website. Robust debate is ok. But If it allows hate, vulgarv insult t...

There is no escape from that, but I hope for greater good the publishers and the Author will forgive me. There is an escape from it.. don't copy his book.. translate it yourself or hire/contract someone to do so.. what you are saying is " I have no option but to rob someones house.. I hope he can f...

As per my understanding, the raza system has indeed existed since the time of Prophet Muhammad.. however, the degree to which this power and authority has been abused and has been started to be applied on things which should not require a raza and only done to extend their control over people is a ...

I do not believe that trying to discredit people like TS MB and MS or collecting books and documents against them or proving the lack of a nass will help with anything. If anything, they will get a new villan to boo at and show the world how jealous others are of them which will fuel the love of th...

I do not believe that trying to discredit people like TS MB and MS or collecting books and documents against them or proving the lack of a nass will help with anything. If anything, they will get a new villan to boo at and show the world how jealous others are of them which will fuel the love of th...

Agree with you Kseeker. But "educating" Bohras is a tall order. An individual here and there might see the light, like "awakendsoul" (http://www.dawoodi-bohras.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=11489), but for a real change to take place we need a mass awakening and that I'm afraid is not possible, at ...

I do not believe that trying to discredit people like TS MB and MS or collecting books and documents against them or proving the lack of a nass will help with anything. If anything, they will get a new villan to boo at and show the world how jealous others are of them which will fuel the love of the...

I think the family tree is relatively simple, Grandson of Syedna Taher Saifuddin RA, Nephew of Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin RA, Son of Syedna Khuzema Qutbuddin RA. Unlike you-know-who, Syedna Taher Fakhruddin does not claim to be a direct descendent of the Prophet Mohammed (SAW). Yes, consistent wit...

Munafiqeen during the time of Syedna Qutbuddin Shaheed used to claim that Bohras are Mushrik. What's left of them today? Nothing. Nafisa whoever you are, will not be remembered but the name Syedna Mufaddal Saifuddin will always be remembered by lakhs of mumineen forever. I didn't know this topic ex...

Agno I was not trying to make two wrong one right, but trying to expose your hypocrisy blaming Muslims and Arabs and when historical facts are put in front of you, you decided to go easy way, So if two wrongs do not make one right why blame Muslims alone all the time. Why not highlight the Muslim a...

You idiot! I can buy a Mercedes for 4000 less at the dealer next door and you are suggesting that if I want to spend 4000 less, I buy a Honda... I agree with SBM dawat tours are rip off. For Much Less you can stay right outside haram shareef and pay a lot less with some private tours. So you can al...

The way you use "raza" is the way Hindus use vedic astrology or gypsies use tarrot cards.. at least the later two have some sort of system behind the way they do their readings... Now - you say it's not a legal binding contract.. but do you know what happens to people who ignore the raza and do wha...

What are you talking, you can NOT do Umrah or HAJJ without the Raza, I donot know which Jamaat do you go to or who is your Aamil Can you name your Child without RAZA or can you name your child of your choosing? You also mentioned you can NOT start a new business without RAZA if I am not using DAWAT...

Has anyone else also heard that SMS has internally announced his son, Hussain Bs Burhanuddin as his successor? "Apparently", all the formalities have been done but has been kept silent from the public and will be announced at an opportune moment...

Can anyone confirm this?

What I like to think will happen is that after the US leaves Afghanistan, The taliban will regain control of Afghan and then come to conquer India.. yet once again.. they will have massive support from the hundreds of millions of muslims in India who will more than welcome the mughal raj... they wi...

All the doctors I speak to give me a timeframe of atleast 6 months for the Covid to come under control.. unless they find a cocktail of anti-virals which can do the trick.... given this lengthy duration, I wonder what will the situation at Ashara.. with hardly any travel allowed and people all paran...

He is digging an abyss in which to bury all opposition. The Saffron group (BJP and other right wing parties) won a resounding victory over the rest by winning 353 out of 542 seats. A margin of 189 is no small feat. That large a number reflects the mood of the country. That majority translates into ...

I find the simple argument quite convincing....since there is a chair, it must have a maker. Hence, since there is a Universe, it must have a creator. What part of it did you not understand? Unless of course you are so lacking in imagination that you are not willing to make room for a grand purpose...

I believe it was his grandfather, Fayz Allah Hamdani who was the first to testify in court that there was no Nass to the 47th Dai.. He was, ofcourse, shunned from the community. His great grand father, Mohammed Ali Hamdani was apparently a titan when it came to Ismaili belief knowledge... Has scribe...

Doesn't Pinocchio's nose seem to be getting longer? Wikipedia excerpt.JPG SMS is now a direct descendant of Rasulullah ? Maybe Lacewalla was not wrong in the direction he was going a few years ago..... Mubarak to the Jamea folks who maintain his Wikipedia page. Pinocchio must be wailing away today ...

Qadir read a little history before you exhibit your ignorance here. Syedna Dawood bin Qutub Shah, because of who we are called Dawoodi Bohras has hiked Suleiman to Akbar’s court and it took him three years of a legal battle before he was declared rightful Dai! So yes a dai in history has had to fig...

During the 23 years of Muhammad's time as a prophet, the verses of the Quran were memorized as they were revealed, and about 42 scribes wrote the verses on different materials such as paper, cloth, bone fragments and leather. In ancient times, literacy was a skill that few people had and Muhammad h...

Again missing the point . The Quran in its current recording was done by Khalifa. It did not come down in a book form or order of ayats as we memorize or read. This is fact. Jesus SAW was not preaching prophet hood in the cradle. The Imam Bohra believe is a concept created recently. The 2 year old ...

Question is not evil, the answers are good or bad. I asked do Bohra and Shia agree the book they read in paper form was under direction of Khalifa Umar. They get their children recite this without knowing the meaning or source. Yet same curse this great servant of Islam. [/quote] The Quran in it's ...

Salaam Everyone I am starting this thread here to dissect the Myths taught in Sabaq. As everyone knows people who attended the Sabaqs are given Oaths not to discuss even with their parents or spouses but the word always leaks out, So let us put those leaks here and ask some of our learned people on...

The position of Dai-al-Mutlaq has always been there... Mazoon-al-Mutlaq, Dai-al-Mutlaq, Dai-al-Balagh, Hujjat-al-Lail, Hujjat-an-Nahar,Bab-ul-Abwab are designated positions under the imam which have been there from the "start"... you gain those positions based on ilm and amal.. and ofcourse, as per...

Now, I have a strong reason to believe that SBM is either a non-bohra or he/she has literally no knowledge about this community’s past. Raja Bharmal and Raja Tarmal probably existed before the birth of 21st Imam. They were in no capacity dais. First dai to be a descendant of Indian people or maybe ...

Does anyone know if these books:
Taaweel-ud-Daim
Asaas-ul-Taweel

by Syedna Qazi Noman were ever translated in English and if so, anyone has them?

If not, would anyone know where to get these books from in any language so that I could commission a translation in english..

thanks!

" but wearing rida is part of islamic law for woman which is to be enforced." Which Islamic Law? where did you get it? "Naming your children is a choice which people follow and if they want to keep a different name on their passport and other documents they are free to do so." Then why grown ups we...

SHU CHOTE MOULA -MALIK SAHEB KHAFA CHE? DAWAT NE KHTRAMA MUKI RAHYA CHE? Taja samachar mujab, Mecca Moazzam ma Haj na wakhat e Amirul Haj Shezada Malekul Ashter Saheb e Ali Qader Moula ni Raza wagar ne khaas kari Aqa Moula na Farman virudh je amalo kidha che te babt e Aqa Moula ghana Naraj che. Mou...