Dawoodi Bohra Forum

What is the proof that Bukhari has not forged the hadith above? No proof, he could have forged and he has forged. BJ Question Hz Bukhari RA was Masoom or not does not arise at all. Hz Bukhari was scholar who collected Ahadith from many. He scrutinized them to best of his ability and judged them in ...

Shehzaada, How will you or anyone like you will prove that all that is written in Bukhari and Muslim is totally correct? Were duo 'masoom'? No. They are subject to all human errors and weakness, thus they are subject to mistakes in their work. Now which part of their work is correct and which not? ...

BJ wrote Only your etc, etc & etc have ran away from Islam Jihaad leaving behind Prophet s.a.w.w. & Mola Ali a.s. to face enemies of Islam. Our Imam Hussain a.s. martyr not fled, Hasanpheer a.q. martyred not fled, Syyedna Qutbuddin martyr not fled. It is only your etc, etc and etc who fled fearing ...

shehzaada wrote:@badribhai, do read this too

I have read all and punctured all air from you, will do same to this article too. But you were unable to counter the factual truths I enlightened to you all blinds and intellectually dishonest.

badribhai so who is your authorized iMAM? who has run away? Only your etc, etc & etc have ran away from Islam Jihaad leaving behind Prophet s.a.w.w. & Mola Ali a.s. to face enemies of Islam. Our Imam Hussain a.s. martyr not fled, Hasanpheer a.q. martyred not fled, Syyedna Qutbuddin martyr not fled....

shehzaada wrote:Yes Bukhari was preserved exactly how Quran was preserved, if you reject bukhari , prepare to reject Quran too and hence become kafir/

Prove above? You and alike have rejected Quran and follow your own fancies hence you all are munafiq indeed, besides being kaafir.

Muslim = one who follows the Islamic rules and regulations. And not the one follow his own whims and fancies to accept and reject any dictum. Non-Bohras use their own discretion to accept or reject dictums of Islam hence they all are not Muslim. They are elevating themselves to equal level of Prophe...

Muslim = one who follows the Islamic rules and regulations. And not the one follow his own whims and fancies to accept and reject any dictum. Non-Bohras use their own discretion to accept or reject dictums of Islam hence they all are not Muslim. They re elevating themselves to equal level of Prophet...

badribhai, you seem to again not willing to digest the fact that prophet pbuh never appointed anyone as his successor, which I clarified many a times on this forum, neither Ali, Abu Bakr , none were explicitly \officially declared in unequivocal termsbecause the prophet pbuh had come with all thing...

SHAPUR, THERE is SAHIH hadith which clearly answers your question , that prophet pbuh did explicitly indicate that he wanted Abu Bakr ALONE to take his place: Jubair bin Mutim Radhiallohu ‘anhu narrates that a woman came to the Prophet Sallallohu alaihi wasallam who ordered her to return to him aga...

@badrjanabdo read this main post Shehzaada, How will you or anyone like you will prove that all that is written in Bukhari and Muslim is totally correct? Were duo 'masoom'? No. They are subject to all human errors and weakness, thus they are subject to mistakes in their work. Now which part of thei...

If we assume that Hz. Abu Bakr lead the prayers - how does it this make him as legal nominee and successor of Prophet s.a.w.w.? Previously many others have been appointed by Prophet s.a.w.w. to boss over Hz. Abu Bakr and latter has prayed under former's Imamat! So by your reasoning that person shoul...

Alwi Bohras Dai and Tahir Saifuddin are ditto alike and exactly are like your 1/2/3 = none of them authorised by Allah, none of them hold any religious office. Their all actions will be materialistic, filled with selfish motives. Islam has nothing to do with all above. A/2/3/4 All 4 were not author...

(1) Sunni contends for Prophet Mohammed s.a.w.w. that he is not infallible and have indeed committed errors. Mazallah. But same Sunni's for Bukhari & Muslim contends their work of 'Sahih' (or they are) infallible!!! Sunnis do not have any basis to believe why should they treat Bukhar & Muslim Sahih ...

Ghulam Mohammed bhai, You are right, I can vouch for you: Tahir Saifuddin has distorted, defaced and misrepresented many things/proofs to appear as if he is legitimate. Alwi Bohras Dai and Tahir Saifuddin are ditto alike and exactly are like your 1/2/3 = none of them authorised by Allah, none of the...

Can Badrijanab reply if Akbar and Jehangir were 'AUTHORISED' to declare the Dai of their times as correct? If that was Fateh Mubeen why cry on Aurangzeb's decision? And have you done any 'independent research' on why Qutubudin was killed? Do you know 'all'??? WC, What shameless creature you are! Yo...

Even 1/2/3 have never dared to falsely claim that they are appointed by Allah, nor anyone from Ummaiyyad or Abbasi dared to make such Godly claims. But Aurangzeb topped all to falsely claim that Aurangzeb (monarch/caliph) is appointed by Allah!!! So besides his all tons of other sins, this claim of ...

Re: Sunan Abu Dawood, (Book #8, Hadith #1424): Narrated Ubayy ibn Ka'b: Al-hasan reported: Umar ibn al-Khattab gathered the people (in tarawih prayer) behind Ubayy ibn Ka'b (who led them) . He used to lead them for twenty days (during Ramadan, and would not recite the supplication except in the seco...

It cannot be used as means of earning livelihood. badrijanab, teri aqqal kya ghans charne ko gayee hai? With your idiotic logic, it would be ok for me to not pay the shop keeper for the Quran. I would advise you not to do that nahin to shop keeper apne joote se teri durgati banayega. Islam (Bohra m...

These are all concocted lies , why would a person of Aurangzeb rah. stature would meddle with the obscure Bohra , unless they commit open blasphemies? I am sure that even if Aurangzeb rah. ordered the execution than there has to be serious and proven charges against Qutubuddin. There is a strong re...

shehzaada wrote:badribhai, can you write the above sentence using hadya?

"Shopkeeper gifted me Quran and I reciprocated by gifting (=hadiya) him $..."

Quran cannot be commoditised to be bought/sold as merchandise. It cannot be used as means of earning livelihood.

anajmi wrote:I can actually purchase the quran separately.

O' moorkhanand & intellectually baimaan Anajmi,

Better to use word "Hadiya" than "purchase".

There is no Sunni Islam. those who do not follow XYZ version of Islam but only follow Quran and authentic Sunnah of prophet have come to be known as Sunni Muslim. 1) Who authorised work of Bukhari, Muslim, etc to be AUTHENTIC sunnah? No one. Sunni ASSUMES & IMAGINE that their Siha-Sitta is complete...

anajmi wrote:badrijanab is now out of luck because porus has turned off his PM!!!

Moorkhanand,

Teri durgati banegi after April 5th. Inshallah. Tab tak tere ko mohlat he, like shaitan have mohlat.

Assalam Alaikum, This is indeed an exhaustive and interesting list of books. However which ones are currently available for general public ? I do have Daim Al Islam (English). Really keen to find Uyun Al Akhbar (either gujarati or english) and Tanbih al Ghafilin( english ot gujarati). Would really ...

Dear Porus bhai,

It is unfortunate to learn that you have switched-off PM. That makes me concerned! Hope you are okay.

I wish you best of health and smiling long life.

Best regards,

Badrijanab.

In Quran, In Nahjul Balagha or in other authentic literature - no where it is mention that on death of any relatives or on martyrdom of any Muslim warrior in Islamic jihad Prophet Mohammed s.a.w.w. or Mola Ali a.s. or Imam Ali Zainul Abideen a.s. have never ever done chest beating or punished self ...

In Quran, In Nahjul Balagha or in other authentic literature - no where it is mention that on death of any relatives or on martyrdom of any Muslim warrior in Islamic jihad Prophet Mohammed s.a.w.w. or Mola Ali a.s. or Imam Ali Zainul Abideen a.s. have never ever done chest beating or punished self w...

It is my personal advise to poor Mumins to contact good character Muslim leaders for quick solution. Kothar is worst. Others Muslim leaders are further worst, in true Islamic sense all non-Bohras are not Muslims indeed = Prophet Mohammed s.a.w.w. said all except one sect will go to hell, and Muslim...

AMAFHH wrote:Does Nahjul Balagha exist in Bohra Islamic Studies ?
i asked this question because this Book was Compiled by Abul Hassan sayyid Muhammad Radhi and he was a great great scholar of Ithnasheri Shia .

Dear AMAFHH,

Refer link: viewtopic.php?f=14&t=9361