Dawoodi Bohra Forum

Only alike can be pitched for partners e.g. only humans can register for a Partnership firm; Pride of Lions are alike and are all partners in their Pride; donkey is not like lion hence he cannot be part of Pride. etc. A leaf of Neem tree, crow and human cannot register for Partnership firm in any co...

Dear Ozdundee, To make it simple: Officially there were no sects in Islam during the life of Mohamed PBUH. Why? Because like every successful organisation there has to be ONLY one leader at the top of hierarchy. So was Mohamed PBUH. The final words in matter of any dispute/debate was that of Mohamed...

Inna lillahe wa inna ilayhe rajeoon.

Wow ! that is quiet sick to know. can anyone from any school of islammic thought put some light on these .... Sounds very brahminish from the caste system prevailed in India. these brahmins could fornicate with lower caste women and not obliged to marry them. Isnt quran against fornicators ? Isnt I...

khokawala wrote:@munira rv also see this as the answer to first question

Idiot, Prophet Mohamed PBUH has not remained illiterate since, sometime after revelation of Quran started! Your beginning itself is wrong, you may go as far as u like, but as your beginning is wrong - you end up wrong, all your life is waste.

Quran commands: Lakum deenoqum walaydeen, no force but freewill prevails in faith. All non-Bohras have their terrorist wing, they justify their terrorism with their non-Bohra doctrines = doctrines of all non-Bohras is not in compliance with above verse of Quran. Please note: Kothar by their action i...

Q1) How today's generation will determine if Mohamed PBUH was really on HAQ (a Prophet) and not otherwise? And if Quran is the HAQ words of Allah? Q2) Can you cite proof if Allah exist? Remember inference is not equal to proof. Do not cite inferences, cite material evidence. And there after how tod...

wow amazing and I am sure they all claim to be on HAQ, now I wonder how come today's generation know actual HAQ . only coming of Imam is solution to all this.[/color] Q1) How today's generation will determine if Mohamed PBUH was really on HAQ (a Prophet) and not otherwise? And if Quran is the HAQ w...

For people with unbiased mind set and who have the ability to "Think", not for transgenders who spew venom :- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHzZRrlZTr8#t=349 Gholam Mohamed, please "Think" - 1. Should there been love between Ahlulbayt and 1-2-3, then as per your line of argume...

For your mis-perceived "fact" - where is the proof? And asking me for the same! Nevertheless, here is my proof: Refer book: Mausam-i-Bahār by Muhammad Ali ibn Jiwabhai, Volume - 2nd. there is no time to read can u just explain what is in it? the history we know is maulatena shehre banu wa...

Where else all Ithna Asheri Imam's (Hazrat Musa Kazim till their last Imam) are all sons of non-Muslima bondmaid (women purchased from market or won as war booty and traded later). Is buying women slaves or keeping POWs as concubines; Islamic, moral, legal, ethical ? Yes, they are Islamic, which me...

can u plz explain how maulatena shere banu was muslim before? she belonged to persia and when persia was conquered by ali, she became muslim this is accepted fact. prove it otherwise For your mis-perceived "fact" - where is the proof? And asking me for the same! Nevertheless, here is my p...

Fiate2000, Molatina Banu a.q. w/o Imam Hussain a.s. was Muslima and not bondmaid. So Imam Ali Zain ul-Abideen a.s. was son of Muslima mother. Ithna Asheri's have peculiar habit of pulling down dignified authority peak to valley! - They consider Prophet Mohamed PBUH as son of bondmaid and cite the Ol...

Your Imam didn't go into hiding. He ran away. He disappeared. He abandoned you. You don't have an Imam and you don't have a Dai. As per Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim: 2nd ran away from war of Khaibar, that is called "ran away". When Prophet PBUH died instead of being at side of Prophet P...

Munira aka Badrijanab If you are willing to pay for full page ads in any of the newspaper I will be more than happy to say what you are asking me to. :mrgreen: My Dai = no one. So if you have no DAI how can you call yourself a BOHRA, Dai is appointed by an IMAM who is in PURDAH and for any TRUE PRI...

Let me repeat. Prophet (saw) went into hiding, came out of hiding, conquered Mecca. Abu Bakr (ra) went into hiding, came out of hiding, became khalifa. Your Imam went into hiding, remained in hiding, died in hiding, his next generation remained in hiding, died in hiding, his next generation....... ...

It is not myth - there was 'fitnat' by Jaffer he conspired with Sunni emperors and by force or con got many Bohra mumineen converted into Sunni. So the Imaan of those Bohras was very weak and they gave into temptation, . TELL US WHO IS YOUR DAI? SBM, your Iman is very weak and you gave into temptat...

Prophet (saw) went into hiding, came out of hiding, conquered Mecca. Abu Bakr (ra) went into hiding, came out of hiding, became khalifa. Your Imam went into hiding, remained in hiding, died in hiding, his next generation remained in hiding, died in hiding, his next generation....... still hiding!!!...

An invalid comparison. He didn't stay in the cave for hundreds of years you moron!! His sons and grandsons became khalifa and went to war. The sons and grandsons of your Imams are also hiding. Infact, his entire lineage is a hiding lineage!! Moron, you are fool and ignorant, The Fatimi Imam era is ...

Then why Mohamed PBUH went hiding into cave when the going got tough and kept Ali a.s. on his bed in lieu of himself to save his own life from enemies, you moron? An invalid comparison. He didn't stay in the cave for hundreds of years you moron!! His sons and grandsons became khalifa and went to wa...

fustrate_Bohra wrote:I THINK 100 kg jinoy is a myth, if it was true than the population of dawoodi bohra would have been much more than what is today.

It is not myth - there was 'fitnat' by Jaffer he conspired with Sunni emperors and by force or con got many Bohra mumineen converted into Sunni.

What are you babbling about you moron? Whether Imams are born from bondmaids or not should not be the criteria for determining their worth. Find out if the Imam goes into hiding when the going gets tough. That is what tells you the worth of an Imam!! Then why Mohamed PBUH went hiding into cave when...

This is the same argument that the jews give when insulting the prophet (saw) and his forefathers. They claim that Isaac (as) was born from Ibrahim's (as) wife and Ismail (as) was born from a bondmaid. The prophet (saw) was from the lineage of a bondmaid. What a shame!! Don't worry Anajmi bhai, Jew...

That's what Bohras are 'taught', isn't there a distant possibility that brahmin ancestors were left with no choice but to accept Islam and they would have chosen bohra stream as they felt appropriate from the 'available' streams of Islam at that time? Its very logical that they would have joined th...

All the Fatimi Imams are mother of proper Muslima women.

Where else all Ithna Asheri Imam's (Hazrat Musa Kazim till their last Imam) are all sons of non-Muslima bondmaid (women purchased from market or won as war booty and traded later).

The cover page of Ayatullah Sadruddin Sadar is attached for your reference. You can check your Ayatullah, the authorised person of your sect - he categorically says, the funeral prayer of Hasan Askari was not lead by his (alleged) son Mohammad. What about the tons of narrations mentioned in kitab al...

Ali was the sole person to give the ritual bath with Ibn Abbas and Jibraeel (a.s.) assisting him. This further reinforces the argument of Ali’s caliphate as traditions report that only the Holy Prophet’s (s.a.w.a.) successor can give him the ceremonial bath. This was the Sunnah of all past Prophets...

Munira...can you please give documentary evidence of your statement. Your criticism of the companions was witnessed or recorded by who ? 1. Sahih Bukhari - Book #3, Hadith #114 2. Sahih Bukhari - Book #59, Hadith #717 3. Sahih Bukhari - Book #70, Hadith #573 4. Sahih Bukhari - Book #92, Hadith #468...

Munira you are going off topic what has disturbing Fatema AS got to do by reviewing which books or knowledge source is the baseline of the faith. Yes I agree it could be from Fatema but how was Fatema knowledge gained and how retransmitted. Anyway we will move on. If it was from the Prophet SAW how...

Does Munira Ben realise that Alcohol was banned by the Prophet SAW at a point in time and before that it was not haram according to Islamic ruling . So those who drank it before the ruling .. What is wrong in mentioning the matter of fact ? Let us be careful we apply the edicts and laws that applie...