Dawoodi Bohra Forum

I'm Munira and not badrijanab.

Bohras has no such books that says, "Ali has forecasted names of all Dai's." Someone has misinformed you.

Ithna Asheri are in leadership crises since the day childless young Hasan Asakri passed away without appointing his successor.

33:30 - O Consorts of the Prophet! If any of you were guilty of evident unseemly conduct, the Punishment would be doubled to her, and that is easy for God. 33:31 - But any of you that is devout in the service of God and His Apostle, and works righteousness,- to her shall We grant her reward twice: ...

Gholam Mohamed bhai and Muslim First bhai, Thank you for being afraid of my write-ups. :) Though I must acknowledge I have learn a lot from Hanif bhai, Badrijanab bhai, Porus bhai, Znanwalla bhai and lately I like some work of Silvertongue bhai where he presented categorical traditions from Sahih Bu...

The mysterious boy who without pre and post identity verification appeared on the funeral of Hz. Hasan Askari was made impostor by unknown vested interest as "Ali" son of Hasan Askari, and later name change was made from Ali to Mohamed so it can match with some of the traditions came in Si...

Actually, you and I together have proven the falseness of the assertion that knowing the Imam is necessary in Fatimi Dawat, which is what I have been claiming all along. If knowing the Imam is not necessary, then the Imam himself is not necessary. In your previous post you asked if knowing "NA...

يَوْمَ نَدْعُو كُلَّ أُنَاسٍ بِإِمَامِهِمْ ۖ فَمَنْ أُوتِيَ كِتَابَهُ بِيَمِينِهِ فَأُولَٰئِكَ يَقْرَءُونَ كِتَابَهُمْ وَلَا يُظْلَمُونَ فَتِيلًا فَتِيلًا Abdullah Yusuf Ali: One day We shall call together all human beings with their (respective) Imams: those who are given their record in their rig...

By the way, you people also claim that anyone who dies without knowing the Imam of their time dies a death of jahiliyya. Thank you for saying that this is a false statement. I would like the other Fatimi Dawat champions on this board to take note that knowing the Imam of your time is not necessary....

Do you know the name of your prophet? Prophet Mohamed (S) After you answer that question, answer this question, Do you know the name of your Imam? No. If not knowing the name of the prophet makes you a disbeliever, then what does not knowing the name of the Imam do to you? Nothing. By the way, you ...

Correct. You do not need to know the identity of all prophets as they won't be called as witnesses upon you. They will be called as witnesses upon those to whom they were sent. They are known to the communities to which they were sent. You know prophet Mohammad (saw) because he was sent as a prophe...

Well, if it is Allah that is doing the calling, then, as countless traditions suggest, each Ummah will be called with the prophets that were sent to them. The prophets were also their Imams. Since we know the prophet (saw), whilst the Imam is unknown, it would be better to assume that the Imam refe...

Munira_RV, You do not know your Imam. Neither did your parents or grand parents know their Imam. Since you do not know your Imam, how will you be called with your Imam? anjami bhai, Verse 17:71 - Abdullah Yusuf Ali: One day We shall call together all human beings with their (respective) Imams: thos...

[Pickthal 17:71] On the day when We shall summon all men with their record, whoso is given his book in his right hand - such will read their book and they will not be wronged a shred. Imam in 17:71 is used for book of deeds. يَوْمَ نَدْعُو كُلَّ أُنَاسٍ بِإِمَامِهِمْ ۖ فَمَنْ أُوتِيَ كِتَابَهُ بِيَ...

Refer to Quran 17:71 and 21:73. Both aayat have word Imam and Aimma (plural of Imam). And both verse speak Imam in leadership position. I must tell, Muslim First bhai, you do not have basic etiquette! I want to discuss some particular thing and instead of constructively participating you are deraili...

Can the esteemed member of this forum present their contention in reference to topic? Lets discuss this topic and learn.

At the time of marriage Aisha & Hafsa have not committed punishable crimes. Knowing futures sins don't make a person guilty in present. One cannot be punished in present for the sins she will commit in future. None of the Fatimi Dawat books acknowledge on your point #4. Per Bukhari & Muslim...

If Jibraeel did visit Hussain, why didn't he bring a solution with him to the problem? He could've given instructions to Hussain on how to defeat Yazid and get victory which would've actually prevented the shia sunni split and the bloodshed that we see today!! 2) Secondly, we have also heard that N...

i have following doubts ; 1) why rasolallah saw married is two daughter to Usman while we have been told that he is not good muslimmmmmm !!!!!! 2) why rasolallah saw got married with Abubakar's daughter ? while he is not good muslimmmm!!!!!!! 3) why rasolallah saw got married with Umar's daughter ?...

Just like bohras like to call themselves Abde Syedna, the pagans used to call themselves Abde Laat or Abde Uzza. Bohras go to raudat tahera and perform sajda to the grave. They ask the grave inhabitant to help them, when Allah says in the Quran that they have no capability to help or even listen to...

Bohras says, "La ilaha illallah". They don't claim that they worship grave, contrary they will reject anyone who will consider grave as God and worship it. Please give your lines of factual arguments which makes Bohris as grave worshippers otherwise be fair to them and don't paint them wha...

Why are you westing time and energy to prove Shia and many Sunnis are grave worshipper? For knowledge purpose I want to learn arguments forwarded by Sunni's/Wahabi's on why they call particularly Bohras as grave worshippers? I sincerely believe Bohras are not grave worshippers. Let's exchange knowl...

Salaam,

Can the respected members here advise in details with proof why Sunni's / Wahabi's / Salafi's call Bohras as grave worshippers?

Shucran

The reason why it has not been demolished The scholars have explained the shar’i rulings concerning the building of this dome and its obvious effects on the followers of bid’ah’ who have developed an attachment to this structure and its colour, and they praise and venerate it a great deal in their ...

Deeni books are not in purdah, they are accessible freely to all who walk in Hathipole library run by us in Udaipur. Book are non-living being and rest all are living being. Books can't enforce who can and who cannot read it, thus there is no purdah on books. Allah, Ashab-al-Kahaf, Syedna Mohammad (...

Freebohra, why don't your Saudi bosses tear up grave, level the roza / makbars and remove the name plate from Syedna Mohammad ( S ), Abubakr and Omar? Like they did to roza of Syeditina Fatim bint Rasool (S), and roza of all Imams in Jaant al Baki?

Mumineen of Khandwa complaint to Human Rights Commission against Khandwa Aamil for forceful and illicit demand of asking incremental Zakat money more than their income! Can the resourceful people who sympathise with PDB cause, help these Bohra mumineen in escalating their fight to upper echelon of g...

मनाहिल 5 नजमुद्दीन के इस इद्दआ के बाद इब्नाउद्-दावत मे तीन फ़िरके हो ग​ए। पहला तो वह कि जो नस​-खफ़ी और इशारा पर एतमाद कर के इन को मानने लगे यह लोग गुणहगार हैं, न तो उलमा कि तरह है न जुहाल। दूसरा फ़िरका वह जो इन्कताअ का काइल हुआ। यह बुलन्द मकाम उलमा-ए-अबरार का तबका है। तीसरा फ़रीक जिम्मे गफ़ीर जुहाल ...

@ Porus - Why are assuming that Misri Calendar is Cairo centric - for tallying with moon? Please provide proof. Thanks. 'Misri' Calendar was devised by Imam Jafar al-Sadiq. It was initially based on Madina which is 1 hour ahead of Cairo. It came into disuse when Banu Umayya and Banu Abbas took over...

.

बिस्मिल्लाह हिर रहमान निर रहीम शिया इसनाअशरी कि मुस्तनद किताब "मजमउल बहरैन" में नफ़स के माद्दह मे लिखा है, "हुज़ैफ़ा ने मौलाना ज़ाफ़र सादिक (अ) को कहा कि लोग कहते हैं कि रसूलअल्लाह ने शहरे रमज़ान के उनतीस (29) रोज़े ज़्याद किए बनिसबत तीस (30) के। आप ने फ़रमाया वह लोग झूठे हैं। आप (रसू...