Who's The Liar?
NONE of the Qutbi Bohras have ANY proof in relation to any alleged nass on KQ. They have been questioned time and time again, and they keep coming up blank. Not a shred of evidence. When their followers are questioned are cornered into debate, one of the answers they have been instructed to parrot is along the following lines. They say:
"Do you believe that the Mazoon of Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin RA fo 50 years, is lying?"
In short, YES. He is lying.
It is philosophically sound because Dawat History has proven that people in higher positions have gone astray from Dawat. KQ isn't an exception, and this shouldn't shake-up your faith even a bit.
Read: http://qutbibohras.blogspot.com/p/summa ... itnat.html
Their followers use the above rhetoric to play the 'rank' or 'quantity' card, and by using it as 'emotional blackmail', they make it seem impossible and ludicrous.
Syedna al Qadi Noman RA, in his kitaab, Sharh al Akhbar (Vol 1) relates to those detractors who disobeyed the clear Nass on Moulana Ali AS. He says (summary):
[When weak minded people of the ummah are questioned in debate and cornered because they don't have any substantial reply, their most common reply is "Do you mean to refer to 1 & 2 and the other companions that followed them - as infidels (kaafirs)!?"
They must be replied to by saying: "O' ignorant one! If you do not wish to refer to them as kaafirs, then don't, but know this, (by protecting them), you are disobeying, denying and rejecting the clear orders of Rasulullah SAW - hence, that makes you a kaafir instead!"]
In the light of the above bayaan, I address the same to the Qutbi Bohra followers who have no clear proof of Nass, but simply cling on to the above statement. To them, I say:
If you find it difficult to believe that Khuzaima Qutbuddin is lying or call him a liar, then don't. But, by doing this you are disobeying, denying and rejecting the clear orders of the infallible 52nd Dai Mutlaq Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin RA in 1388H 1415H 1426H 1432H and every single day until His wafaat - hence, that makes you a kaafir/liar instead!
You're supporting the same person that kept you away from Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin RA physically during his life and at his janaza, and who is now keeping you away from him spiritually.
The choice is yours.