i think this is a very good read .. answers quite a lot of question! Also related to some posts earlier about Abdeali clearly accepting the NASS makes me feel that the KQ camp either forgot that this was said or just conveniently overlooked it. These are not two different bayans, its the same bayan, where he clearly accepts that "NASS nu azeem amal farmayu" and he goes on to describe on who the NASS was performed and then the dua for tul al umar. How is one supposed to ignore this?
* i can write the whole clip here in english if someone was not able to hear it clearly, do let me know*
In any case, there are some lingering questions in this thread that i really feel have not been given importance. I also really feel that people in this thread have raised some valid points (valid in the eyes of a unbiased person) are pushed away conveniently and are either not commented on or are just forgotten. But honestly, two fundamental questions which i think we all should ponder upon before we make accusations:
1) Why did KQ not go to SMB right after the NASS at RAUDAT TAHERA? Yes, he wasn't present there like many other such instances, but well keeping all that aside, am I really supposed to believe that the second in command was not "allowed" to go meet the DAI (in person) for two years! The ruthba of mazoon is very elevated and i do believe that if he actually made an attempt he would be able to. Was he afraid of something? I have heard arguments that Abdeali tried to reach or something like that, not really sure, but why would abdeali want to reach SMB to talk about this? Where was KQ himself in the two years of the NASS?
2) As per the information on the website, the claim is that SMB asked KQ to keep the apparent nass to himself until it is time to disclose. So that raises a few questions in my head. But the most important is that a few months back, times of india published an article discussing a split within the community and that some people felt that KQ was the heir apparent. Saying so, how did times of india get this news? Inside job? If so then how could this inside person have known such a thing? Was it made up by them or was it shared by KQ himself? If made up by some people, then this whole discussion and the thread in fact is an absolute waste but if in fact KQ did reveal this to someone, he did break a vow to SMB! The DAI that he claims to succeed.
One final point before i wrap up, i do appreciate some of the users raising some logical points. I in no means acknowledge that its true i am merely saying that its logical and i respect it. However, it seems that over the past few days the logical discussions have taken a more hateful approach. It is very obvious that some users have a predefined notion in their head and are digging for proofs, words, actions that would justify their beliefs. But if this is to be dealt with logically than i guess keeping an open mind is a pre-requite.
