adna_mumin wrote:Brother HMALAK - i know the question is addressed to Shz Mufaddal BS, but few days ago the exact same thought ran thru my mind and i wrote this up (produced below for your reference). Would be glad to know what you think of it. ThanksHMALAK wrote:Question to Mufaddal BS with Due Respect:
I would like to highlight one of the most important questions pertaining to the Nass Issue which is going around the community.
I HEARD IN THE FIRST WAAZ OF YOURS AFTER YOU BECAME THE DAAI (FOR ME YOU ARE THE CLAIMANT), THAT BURHANUDDIN SAHAB GAVE YOU THE DIARY IN 1430 HIJRI, BUT YOU DO NOT KNOW THE EXACT DATE. I HAVE A QUESTION THERE, HOW CAN A PERSON WHO IS GOING TO BE THE LEADER OF THE ONE MILLION COMMUNITY FORGETS THE MOST IMPORTANT DATE OF HIS LIFE. THIS IS NOT FOR THE SAKE OF HIS PERSONAL MATTER BUT ALSO FOR THE COMMUNITY AND PROBABLY THE WORLD AT LARGE.
adna_mumin wrote:"Taareekh yaad nathi"
This is an attempt to dissect, discuss and may be bring more ideas out of the Q&A series on Fatemidawat website. There have been few reasons given to convey the message as to why Shz Mufaddal BS cannot be Dai.
Let us take the one about the forgotten date, made famous by the phrase "Taareekh yaad nathi" in the waaz on Imam uz Zaman Milad by Mufaddal BS.
In the Q&A video the claim made is like a person would correctly remember the date of his Nikah (and many other such events of his life) so how could the person claiming to be Dai forget the date on which his Naas that is Burhanuddin Moula RA conveyed to him that he was the mansoos by showing the Letter of 1388 H.
I have the following issue with the reasoning given by Husain BS. That because the supposed event never happened if any arbitrary date was offered then Mufaddal BS ran the risk of someone out of the million Bohras would come forward to claim that either Burhanuddin Moula RA or Mufaddal BS himself were in such, such place on that date.
One thing that is also claimed in the Waaz was that this happened in Mumbai. Here is a problem with this theory.
So question arises if indeed he had to make up a date, do Mumineen not know which dates Moula RA was surely in Mumbai year after year even if one never kept record of his travels?? If that is common knowledge surely he and his group would have thought about it and suggested?
Lailatul Qadr and Urs of Syedna Taher Saifuddin RA are 2 events Moula RA was almost certainly in his last years in Mumbai.
One exception being of his indisposition few years ago when in Shehrullah he (Moula RA) stayed in London.
So if indeed Mufaddal bs wanted to make up a date he surely could have chosen either of these 2 events? That he did not means?
What I am asking is Can it be possible for a person who claims to be knowing everything in the House of a Mumeen, does not know the exact date of the Event which makes part in the History of Dawoodi Bohras. Making up a date is altogether Different thing which I am not getting into because I know everything in this religion is made up of something which is baseless. If I am asked about the same, I would have known the exact time, forget about Date.
Seeking its importance I would only like to know the date and not asking any clarification about the same and where was he and Syedna Burhanuddin (RA) at that time. That job would probably done by the Mumenin themselves.