Bohra Springjames wrote:I can relate to your predicament . It's same like Agnostics , Atheists , Non Practicing Christians + Jews making fun of us Islamics by quoting supernatural occurrences listed in the Koran.Bohra spring wrote:Regardless of the source of the information or the context...would you really think and believe Husain AS had a verbal communication with a horse !
Can that scenario ever be replicated where a human being in severe situation of tragedy would converse with a horse. conversation is 2 way...it is where a human utters words and the horse responds with logic and reasoning.
Your claim goes to imply the horse was a super horse that had intelligence. Not a simple horse that grunts or whatever sound it makes and has affinity for its master. Once you carefully consider this then try to think what must have really happened and I bet you it may have been jestures and assumption but not conversation or discussing what happens in hereafter.
When religious fanatics go on overdrive in their blind emotional love to explain an event they unconsciously fall into traps that questions credibility or logical reasoning.
Sometimes I wonder whether they need to over dramatise the events ...or is it to spice it up and attract affection.
I will not be surprised if the response is why not why can there not be a super intelligent horse !
Out of morbid curiosity , do you believe everything written in the Koran ?
I notice you are quite active on other threads and I hope it isn't cowardice in play when you have failed to answer a very basic question here.