fulan ibn fulan wrote:Ghulam, Kothar was also a cananite God, but that doesn't mean the Kothar are based on him does it? Everything has to be taken into context. There is a surname Kothari now in India and the original Kothari were care-takers for the Kings palace. Although it seems to me that a lot of people assume that they are infact cunning,devious people who take money from people. I don't know if you know any people from Kothar, maybe you should actually ask them what they do.
Maqbool, I understand why KQ didn't do laanat, he had fear for himself and his followers, I can understand that given that we heavily out weigh them in numbers but all these attacks on his supporters should not reflect badly on the community as a whole, all those people burning his effigies were doing it on their own accord, not because of farmaan. Muffadal Maula would never say ke logo ne pakri ne marjo.
I don't want to sit here and keep justifying the laanats because I personally feel it is okay and I have said this before, I don't want to keep repeating myself and let the same arguement keep coming back. Zinger I totally agree with you that people used to make fun of Burhannuddin Maula on this forum long beofore his wafaat. But I just have to ask, why do you have that view on someone who went against maula directly?
Just out of curiosity, I know that before wafaat there used to be many forums on Muffadal Maula, were there any which were solely dedicated to KQ? It seems he has become the topic of conversation now, but before when did you talk about him? And also again just out of curiousity, could someone send me a link if any, which was written before wafaat on how they thought the nass was staged, and an orchastated attemt to take control of dawat?
Fulan bhai, i think what you mean to ask is an extremely personal question and i would have preferred to not answer it here. since you ask me however, here it is.
I have given my Misaq to Mufaddal Maula. So you know where i stand
I cannot and will bring myself to give Lanat to ex Mazun Maula for the simple reason that as long as Burhanuddin Maula RA was alive, he kept him near him. Reasons best known to him.
I am not believing nor am i denying any of the rumours/proofs/stories/justifications/validations etc being placed.
As of now, only Allah knows who the true Dai is. If people knew who the true Dai was, there would be no split.