JavedhJuma wrote:Can you please tell me what scholarly consensus you are talking about? The ones who have taken away Allah SWT's right to Judge people, or the Ulema who says:araz5253 wrote:all of the above points are conjectures. Ismailis who follow Isailism do not belong to Islam by scholarly consesnsus and what charitable activities they might be doing is irrelevant , even Jews do a lot of charity and have an apparently "peaceful" appearence.
https://ismailimail.wordpress.com/2015/ ... -on-islam/
Please write to the Ulema above and tell them that charitable activities the Ismailis are doing are irrelevant and while you are at it, please ask them to re-write the Qur'an in which Allah SWT stresses the importance of charity again and again.
Acccording to you, Muslims do not do charities????? "Jews do a lot of charity and have an apparent peaceful appearance?????? Do you know what you are saying. I think you are saying Muslims do not do charity and they are violent?????
Please go to African countries, Afghanistan, Middle East, Pakistan, India, Tajikistan, etc. and ask them "if our charities are irrelevant and our peaceful attitude is irrelevant? Would they prefer Talibans, ISIS, etc. instead.?"
And do you think brother Edhi, who is single handedly taking care of orphans and other human beings, and is peaceful, that his charity is not important?
Are you saying people who do charity are not important?
Allah decides the rules and the implementation is fard on mankind , infact those who dont judge by what ALLAH has revealed are kafir, being non judgemental is zen philosophy. Allah himself commands us to judge , only the khawarij invented this false rhetoric that "ALLAH IS JUDGE SO HUMANS SHOULD NOT JUDGE" IF that is the case then why the need for shariah? Qazis?.
regarding charity then charity by Mushrikeen is virtually useless and unprofitable for them and they will get all rewards for it in this world only,nothing in the eternal life for a single crime of being a Mushrik. Ismailis ,Jews etc may do a lot of charity to show to the world but that will help them only in this world. INSTEAD of giving charity first they should give themselves charity by learning Islam and following it like how prophet pbuh followed, only then the charity would be useful for you.