anajmi wrote: Zakat during the time of khilafat was equivalent to the tax a normal person pays to the government. Try not giving tax and see how the government declares war on you.
Prophet SAW used to collect Zakah as he was ordered to . There was no decree of a declaration of war against the people who didn't give Zakah during his lifetime or for all of end times. Did the changing of meaning of zakah or the authorization of a government/khilafat come from Allah Ta'ala or his Rasul SAW ? It was Abu Bakr made who had no authorization whatsoever to declare war on people who refused to give zakah.
With the disbanding of the khilafat, zakah is now a personal responsibility.
During Rasullah SAW 's lifetime it was a personal responsibility . Then during the time of khilafat , new rules were set in without any authorization from Allah Ta'ala or Rasullah SAW. After khilafat , we are back to personal responsibility . This is an example of a " bidah " set in stone if there ever was.
The institution of the Dai is a corrupt institution that pilferages the zakah money of the bohras.
That is just your opinion . There has been no pilferation of any kind by the Duat Mutlaqeen RA and present Dai TUS in my opinion.
During the khilafat, the khalifa was responsible for the poor.
Wasn't Rasullah SAW responsible for his ummah in his lifetime ? It is a big accusation on Prophet SAW that Abu Bakr had to introduce bidah because Prophet wasn't far sighted to know that declaring war on Muslims who refused to pay zakah was necessary . Nozubillah .