From the "many" that he collected hadith - who will vouch they are speaking truth?Muslim First wrote:BJWhat is the proof that Bukhari has not forged the hadith above? No proof, he could have forged and he has forged.
Question Hz Bukhari RA was Masoom or not does not arise at all.
Hz Bukhari was scholar who collected Ahadith from many.
He scrutinized them to best of his ability and judged them in different categories.
Even one hadith has different wording since they came from different sources. He recorded all kind of Ahadith.
No body has accused him to be forgerer except some imbecile like you.
There is still scholarly work going on scrutinizing Ahadith.
Imam Albani RA's work is good one.
What those "many" spokes - who will authenticate that Bukhari wrote it correctly and fully, and not took a part here and there to justify his Abbasid aaqa's?
Abbasi caliph made him added (forged) hadith to legitimatise their caliphate as Islamic rules!!!
What shame and tinyful brain is of yours - that you consider Prophet Mohammed s.a.w.w. as fallible and your Bukhari & Muslim work as infallible!!!!