Dawoodi Bohra Forum

Universaldad, By using abusive language, you have just proved my point. In Raudat Tahera incident, Dr. Moiz defied Burhanuddin Aqa's RA instructions and instead of reciting ya sayyadus shohoda marasiya, he announced nass and then asked MS to speak. After this, what credibility does MS, Dr. Moiz and ...

Adam,

Appreciate your response but you have side stepped my question. Or, may be I asked a rhetorical question. However, I will elaborate.

I know you agree with me that Syedna Qutbuddin TUS was mazoon of Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin RA until his last breath. My point was that when Mazoon of Syedna ...

James,

According to Mufaddali doctrine, up to amil's wife everyone is infallible. There is a recent example on this forum in which an amil's wife was caught texting to "upar na saheb" in the middle of matam majlis, and guess what, instead of her apologizing - because she can't be wrong - the person ...

So Adam what are your credentials to interprete STS RA risala. Do you realize that STS RA himself taught this risala and dawat doctrines to both SMB RA and SKQ TUS? What makes you think you can understand it better by checking the meaning on google? Who is digging the hole here?

Dai is a living ...

Adam,

You make several points regarding validity of private nass under dawat doctrines, which have been also made in the two websites referred by you. My understanding is that these websites are on anonymous basis and those who write on them do not reveal their identities. They also indicate that ...

Adam, it is interesting to me that you are basing your argument about SKQ nass by saying that private nass is not allowed in dawat doctrines. It comes across to me as if you agree that SMB RA may have said this to SKQ but that it is not counted under dawat doctrines. STS RA's risala clearly says ...

after accepting Islam was she business woman or she gave away responsibilities to nabi(s)?

Since you claim to be islamic scholar, I am sure you know the answer. I find it so interesting that just to prove your point, you are thoughtlessly ready to imply that Molatona Khadija AS would have done ...

I find it strange that even according to MS' version, he is relying on other persons input that nass was done on him. Whether it is his brothers or Moiz or some letter. They claim that MS was always with Burhanuddin Mola RA, but in all the time never once did Burhanuddin Mola RA directly told him ...

if you know about islamic shariya you will find woman are not allowed to work until her family is in dire need of money and there is no other option for the family but to send their woman for work. (which is not required in this case, as you mentioned they have lots of money)
[/u].

Did you know ...

I agree. All those on MS side do need to ponder over this carefully. MS claims to be a dai of Rasullulah (SAW), then why is he not the one calling for Mubahila? MS claims to be a dai of Imam Hussain (AS), then why is he not the one holding Quran and saying so? All we are hearing is abusive language ...

Noor, This forum is full of examples showing opulence and extravagance of MS. Whether they are custom made rail cars, air conditioned horse carriages, expensive hunting trips, beach front houses or ziyafats where servers bring dishes across swimming pool. I am sure I have missed hundreds of such ...

Thanks for detailed explanation. Given the historical significance of Mubahila, if Shahzada Muffadal Saifuddin thinks he is on haq, he lost an important opportunity to prove himself. By not showing up, one is forced to compare him with the Christians of Najran.

What is the meaning of Mubahila?