Coming to the forum after a long absense.
Not much of exciting new stuff except could not find my dear old Anajmi.
Is he found some meaningfulness in life or porus forced his exit? I know that relation with Porus was not too good at the later stage.
Where are you Dear Lord Anajmi
-
Above Average Bohra
- Posts: 362
- Joined: Wed May 11, 2005 4:01 am
Re: Where are you Dear Lord Anajmi
Yeah I miss him too. The three horned God drove him away.
Re: Where are you Dear Lord Anajmi
What made you lapse if I may ask? I too had left this forum for a while but decided to come back because of recent developments somewhat in my good faith.Originally posted by jamanpasand:
Coming to the forum after a long absense.
-
jamanpasand
- Posts: 468
- Joined: Sat Oct 29, 2005 4:01 am
Re: Where are you Dear Lord Anajmi
Sorry ! My friend is there. This time under
Above Average Bohra
Above Average Bohra
Re: Where are you Dear Lord Anajmi
Yes, he apeears to have admitted it himself!!
***********************************************
Above Average Bohra
Active
Member # 779 posted February 04, 2008 08:21 PM
________________________________________
quote:
________________________________________
Even Aisha admitted later in her life that she regrets going to war with Ali.
________________________________________
Then that should close this discussion.
quote:
________________________________________
their acts then by that logic Hazrat Ali should not have fought her army.
________________________________________
May be he shouldn't have. Who knows. Hazrat Ali was a human, may be he made a mistake. Here is where the Sunnis have gotten this right. They respect both Hazrat Ali and Hazrat Aisha as per the commandment of Allah and his prophet. They don't worry about what happened between them. The shia, being worshippers of Hazrat Ali, can't. So they go against the quran. The quran asks you to worship Allah, but the shia worship Hazrat Ali, so it becomes ok for them to reject the quran.
By the way, just so you know, I can't login with my other id (should be easy for you to guess) - I was able to post with it earlier because of cookies left on my laptop.
________________________________________
Posts: 288 |
**********************************************
anajmi
Prolific
Member # 228 posted February 01, 2008 08:57 PM
________________________________________
quote:
________________________________________
The reason for salt, rather than bread, is that Ali ibn Abi Taalib always took salt before iftaar.
________________________________________
This is based on which hadith? What was the prophet's custom for iftaar? Was it salt? Did Hazrat Ali go against the practice of the prophet?
________________________________________
Posts: 5526 |
Above Average Bohra
Active
Member # 779 posted February 02, 2008 12:51 AM
________________________________________
For some reason I can't login using my other id anymore, so I am going to post using this id.
There is no mention of Hazrat Ali performing iftaar using salt anywhere in Daimul Islam in the chapter on Fasting. There is however mention of one instance where he opened his fast alongwith the prophet using milk. There is mention of how helping someone open his fast even with a date or water is a big virtue.
If these claims cannot be backed up (even from a doubtful source), then I am going to have to conclude that people are hanging their BS around Hazrat Ali's neck!!
***********************************************
Above Average Bohra
Active
Member # 779 posted February 04, 2008 08:21 PM
________________________________________
quote:
________________________________________
Even Aisha admitted later in her life that she regrets going to war with Ali.
________________________________________
Then that should close this discussion.
quote:
________________________________________
their acts then by that logic Hazrat Ali should not have fought her army.
________________________________________
May be he shouldn't have. Who knows. Hazrat Ali was a human, may be he made a mistake. Here is where the Sunnis have gotten this right. They respect both Hazrat Ali and Hazrat Aisha as per the commandment of Allah and his prophet. They don't worry about what happened between them. The shia, being worshippers of Hazrat Ali, can't. So they go against the quran. The quran asks you to worship Allah, but the shia worship Hazrat Ali, so it becomes ok for them to reject the quran.
By the way, just so you know, I can't login with my other id (should be easy for you to guess) - I was able to post with it earlier because of cookies left on my laptop.
________________________________________
Posts: 288 |
**********************************************
anajmi
Prolific
Member # 228 posted February 01, 2008 08:57 PM
________________________________________
quote:
________________________________________
The reason for salt, rather than bread, is that Ali ibn Abi Taalib always took salt before iftaar.
________________________________________
This is based on which hadith? What was the prophet's custom for iftaar? Was it salt? Did Hazrat Ali go against the practice of the prophet?
________________________________________
Posts: 5526 |
Above Average Bohra
Active
Member # 779 posted February 02, 2008 12:51 AM
________________________________________
For some reason I can't login using my other id anymore, so I am going to post using this id.
There is no mention of Hazrat Ali performing iftaar using salt anywhere in Daimul Islam in the chapter on Fasting. There is however mention of one instance where he opened his fast alongwith the prophet using milk. There is mention of how helping someone open his fast even with a date or water is a big virtue.
If these claims cannot be backed up (even from a doubtful source), then I am going to have to conclude that people are hanging their BS around Hazrat Ali's neck!!