I like your last argument .. you have a good point

No, because if they are married, then their urge is not making them do anything haraam.As to our 'urges' and putting them before God - what would you say when straight people want to make love and have sex with partners of opposite sex, are they putting their 'urges' before God??
Wrong comparison. You should be comparing an urge to eat halal chicken versus an urge to eat haraam pork. One is allowed and the other one is not.You have the urge to eat chicken, I have an urge to eat Dal-Chawal ........... both are equally good or both are equally bad.
Correct. There are some ayahs of the Quran which are clear. For eg. Homosexuality is not allowed is amongst the clear messages of the Quran. These clear ayahs are not going to change. Even if we have understood just 10% of the ayahs of the Quran, the ayahs about homosexuality are in those 10% of the understood ayahs.No scholar can claim we have successfully interpreted Quran 100%.
Is there any ayah or Hadith which says homosexuality is shirk?anajmi wrote: Correct. There are some ayahs of the Quran which are clear. For eg. Homosexuality is not allowed is amongst the clear messages of the Quran. These clear ayahs are not going to change. Even if we have understood just 10% of the ayahs of the Quran, the ayahs about homosexuality are in those 10% of the understood ayahs.
That is like saying do not say haraam to haraam. What is haraam is haraam and comparing it with halaal doesn't make it halaal.I had already said do not compare my eating example with eating Halal and Haram
The Quran doesn't give me the option to budge. It is pretty clear.You see you all are not budging in because of your perception that homosexuality is haram.
Yes, outside of marriage even straight sex is haraam. You didn't marry a guy before you had sex with him did you? Show me one homosexual who waited till he married a guy before having homosexual sex. You cannot because that is not how homosexuality works. It is a sin from every angle.Do straight people are advised of similar things?? No, so why us.
Because those ayahs are clear.Why it cannot be of balance 90%??
You probably won't be there to take advantage of the revised interpretation. Homosexuals of that time may enjoy but the interpretation of today says that homosexuality is haraam.but say 200 yeras from now people of that time may correct or revise the interpretation
Unfortunately for you, the Quran is not from humans. God knows the past, present and future.once we believed earth was flat
'Kleptomaniac' too is a mind set but if the person suffering from this problem is caught stealing then he is jailed and not set free. The person cant use the excuse that he is born with this trait to absolve himself from the crime commited due to that trait.JC wrote:Homosexuality is not only sex between two partners of same sex, it is a mind set, it is orientation of a human being, it is 'how' a person is born with some traits
Bro. JC,JC wrote:This is something natural between two willing, consenting adults with no harm cause to any other individual or property.
What an idiot. You just see everything with your islamic topi on and it is easy for you to make such remarks because you were born straight. If you were born a gay, you would know how it feels and how much of an uphill battle it is with the society especially a religious one. If I was a gay it wouldn't have bothered me at all as I'm not religious and don't care much but I feel sorry for the likes of depressed who is in a bad mental state and you're making it worse. While I admire the courage of JC to come out and fight for what he believes in. You have no right to make such remarks unless you were actually in their shoes.anajmi wrote:As per Islam it is a sin and this is amongst the clearest of messages of the Quran. If you are a homosexual, I believe that you should feel depressed and guilty like depressed feels and because he feels that way I have hope that he will be cured of his disease inshaallah. There is a famous tradition where a sinner asks Allah for forgiveness and Allah says I forgive him because my slave recognizes me for my forgiveness. If you expect Allah to cure you, you will be cured. If you do not think it is a sin, then you do not seek forgiveness or cure and you will get neither.HOMOSEXUALITY IS NOT SIN..!!
depressed,
I would suggest that you go for therapy as suggested earlier.
Your scientific research? My backside (wanted to use a stronger word here but didn't for decency sake)...You have no clue what science is or what scientific research is. By the way, reading quran does not comprise of scientific research. Let me repeat my self in bold caps READING QURAN IS NOT SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH...If you are to consider all kinds of compulsions as diseases then I'm sure you'd admit from suffering the 'arguement syndrome' and the 'I am superior syndrome' and the 'I am always right syndrome', etc.anajmi wrote:That it is a disease is simply my opinion based upon my extensive scientific research and analysis. Quran says it is a sin and that should be sufficient. I consider all kinds of sin that become a compulsion in a human, a disease. Unable to control homosexual urge is similar to being unable to control promiscuous urges which is also considered a mental disease. A person who switches his lights on and off multiple times to make sure that they are working is said to be suffering from a disease too. Watching too much porn is also considered a disease.
Boom,anajmi wrote:No.Can you please show me were in the Quran it written that homosexuality is a disease??
Cause I assumed that the people who are reading had some sense. Apparently, I was wrong.Ohh really, then why did you say this
A person with average or above average IQ wouldn't need to ask this question. A person with less than average IQ wouldn't understand the answer, so I won't waste my time.Does Allah (swt) cure sin or forgive them??
Yes, now you are an ex-idol worshiper and a current book worshiper.anajmi wrote:And I am glad about that. Becoming a muslim is more important to me than remaining an abde slave idol worshipper.And you guys ceased to be dawoodi bohras the day you uttered curses to the Syedna....
Good on you for admitting it. I always imagined you to be an ugly looking person with a jungle beard in which dandruff and lice roam freelyanajmi wrote: I am not comparing a homosexual to a murderer, rapist or a thief. I would rather invite a homosexual to my house than the other three cause I am one of the ugliest men you will see.![]()
There is no provision in Islamic sharia to marry two men to each other. So I am not sure how they could've been married according to Islamic Sharia. That is like saying I am going to commit zina according to Islamic Sharia or loot people according to Islamic Sharia (like the Dai does to his abde idiots)!!Two Muslim men married according to Islamic Sharia