Dawoodi Bohra Forum

bohrabhai wrote:http://nelc.uchicago.edu/sites/nelc.uch ... %20EI3.pdf

very eloquently written......mashallah, may god help her with her future endeavors.

yeah nothing new some portions taken frm farhad daftary book the ismailis

salaar wrote:yeah nothing new some portions taken frm farhad daftary book the ismailis

may be you are right or may be you are wrong, doesnt matters.

btw what has muffy wrote so far to boost bohra literature and bohra identity?

What has KQ written for dawoodi bohra identity. Its her daughter who has written and there are many books written by Shz Dr jaafer us sadiq bs s/o Syedna Mufaddal asaifuddin TUS.

Get something new to compare.

true_bohra wrote:What has KQ written for dawoodi bohra identity. Its her daughter who has written and there are many books written by Shz Dr jaafer us sadiq bs s/o Syedna Mufaddal asaifuddin TUS.

Get something new to compare.

yeah like " dear husbands if your ladies do not wear rida 24/7 throw them out" and yeah one more " come i will hug you uncle" and yeah " ladies are meant to choose one corner of house do home science keep your husband happy and knead atta and roll some rotis" and according to mufaddal saab " IT is fashion ".

Yet making fool of yourself again. So letme help you with his work. Go and visit this wikipedia page and enhance your knowledge about him.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jafar_us ... _Saifuddin

comeon just compiling history frm different sources is no big deal iam not impressed

A person has taken the efforts to write about our identity and instead of appeciating you guys are finding out mistakes out of it.
I would appreciate if you people can learn to accept somebodys effort.

monsuier 74 alright i appreciate the compilation but honestly there was nothing new all repeated information if there is anything you quote me and i will tell you where it was exhibited already, i remember somebody showed his work on IMAM A.S a detailed history and the political situation of that period, even that was a compilation but a compilation which was quiet tedious and something new for ordinary readers anyways we acknowledge the work

salaar wrote:monsuier 74 alright i appreciate the compilation but honestly there was nothing new all repeated information if there is anything you quote me and i will tell you where it was exhibited already, i remember somebody showed his work on IMAM A.S a detailed history and the political situation of that period, even that was a compilation but a compilation which was quiet tedious and something new for ordinary readers anyways we acknowledge the work

history remains same, what new do you want her to write?

this is not a bollywood script which can be rewritten by adding some more masala every time.

I personally appreciate her effort's. BRAVO.

Again we are starting unfruitful argument but as i said earlier this piece of work is nothing new and has been narrated in many books however some writers have the ability to bring into light the less known facts and then join it with the mainstream, to prove my point you know all the shia ulema keep on searching and reading throughout the year to compile their majlis in such a manner that it carries new angles although history is same and then you know how much difference is there in their charges just because of this quality

bhai salaar, it seems that the editors of The Encyclopedia of Islam, made a grave mistake. They should have invited you to write the article instead of Dr. Bazat Tahera baisaheba!

Br. Salar
The history of Karbala is same, Did SMB or SMS or SKQ can add anything new.

SBM wrote:Br. Salar
The history of Karbala is same, Did SMB or SMS or SKQ can add anything new.

Bro. SBM:

Sorry to contradict you, but yes SMS can add to Karbala history, e.g. we now know that horses can talk, Imam (a.s.) prayed for 51st and 52nd dais, Gibraeel came to talk to Imam Hussein (a.s.), etc. etc.

ok you are right and iam wrong

Its not a question of being right or wrong brother, the fact of the matter is that atleast ONE shehzadi of Saifee Mahal took the pains of writing something knowledgeable instead of spending time on renovating their houses every 6 months, making designer jewelleries and taking salams (envelopes) !

have you forgotten the BU Sahiba Sahifa that was an admirable compilation covering all aspects of religion, have you people ever appreciated that effort the way you are doing now for a small article

I said "Shehzadis" and Busaheba was not a shehzadi !