Dawoodi Bohra Forum

anajmi
I think i specifically pointed out that Mufaddal maula is the Dai and the so called evidence pointed out by kq is very weak.

And what you consider Islamic doctrines are your interpretation of piece meal info you've collect. Most of it doesn't follow sunni or shia.

anajmi,

that's funny, your statements sounds like you know what should and shouldn't be taught...but your writing indicates you have very little knowledge of Islamic doctrines or history in general. What gives you the authority to say the Dai is teaching incorrectly when you yourself don't know?

Al Muizz, exactly why are you on this site based on your statement that I should be off and not exchange with fitnat? Point to you statements, Muffadal Maula (tus) has constantly stated "tamare bhaiyo ne bolavo" referring to the mumineen who are not coming or have weak aqeeda. Most of the ...

Anajmi I think you are missing my point. The dai is only to give dawah outside the community by the raza of the imam az'zaman. There hasn't been one dai in the period of star that has given dawah because it is the imam who instructs what should or shouldn't be said. My example with rasullah and moul...

Salam Al-Muizz, While you responded with a lot of name calling...you didn't actually correct or "debunk" anything I wrote. Alhamdullah on your sabaqs attendance. btw sabaq has a q for qaf not a k for kahf. qibla also has a qaf. When I disagree with someone, I tell them why I disagree and t...

there are many books translated into english published through IIS. most are sold on amazon.com or ibtauris.com

anajmi, the problem with your analysis is you assume you actually know what is right or wrong...without having even an iota of substance behind it. reading some translations of so called sahih hadith and a translation of quran doesn't make you knowledgable...on contrary, if you actually believed the...

Anajmi
Problem is your only using what you feel is right as your belief. You don't believe in dai even though moula ali was a dai of rasullah to yaman. You don't believe in imamate even though it is clearly in hadith. Quran and sunnah are there regardless if you understand them or not.

Anajmi
If you do not believe in the position of dai why are you on this forum?

Secondly you seem to take what you like and leave what you dont. Lakum dinakum walaydin.

salam anjami, this why we should not just cut and paste translation without actually reading the Arabic suratul barat (taubah) Baraatun mina Allahi wa rasoolihi ila alazina ahadtum minaal mushrikeen disassociated from Allah and his Rasul are those who did not keep their pledge/convenant (ahad or mit...

anajmi, read suratul barat. again research something before you speak. exactly who made you the decider of who gets laanat? You say it is ok for people who deserved...who determines this (not you). you reasoning is childish in this manner. If you follow kq...then you should say laanat on sms (na auz...

salams,
there have been many dawat books that are already translated in by the IIS available that review this topic. For example Syedna Naysaburi (ra) and Syedna Hamid Kirmani (ra).

salams, I find it odd that there is discussion so fierce on this issue when no one seems to have verified eithers claims completely. I think the opinions of money should be put to the side...all sides have money. KQ claims nass without witness (not allowed even though he claims it); SMS has witnesse...

salams, khatmul quran is for SMB. We do matam majlis thereafter for aza of Imam Husain (as) as recommended by SMB. The videos are non essential but serve a point. Understand a majority of bohras do not follow the threads of whataps or search for articles on the internet. the youth definitely do...bu...