Look, Aarif,Aarif wrote:AM,Why can't she keep it GENERAL?
The problem with abdes like you is that when people talk in general you or other abdes like you will ask them to provide exact details in-order to validate the authenticity and if they are reluctant do so you will dismiss it as heresay or fake. Now when someone is providing the actual names of the miscreants in her jamaat you are calling it character assasination. You can definitely debate with her by asking her relevant questions on her post to obtain more info and better understand the situation but you cannot dismiss her entire grievance by categorizing it under personal bickering.
As I mentioned in the earlier posting, I don't know any of the characters mentioned in the postings. And NO! To counter your point, I am NOT ASKING for proof of this. Do I believe this exists? Sure! It happens in MOST if not ALL jamaats one way or another. Is this model behaviour? Absolutely not! How can you addres this? Liek we do, talk to the party and ask them straight up what their problem is. It's a jamaat. the jamaat is meant to be cohesive and open. If your jamaat isn't then surely that can't be the fault of Islam, Muslims, Shiaism, is it?